Complete Coverage:

Complete Coverage:
Ft. Hood Shootings

°

Homepage / Detroit Local News
Text Size

Hart Plaza Shooting Suspect Is Free Man

Prosecutor Announces There's Not Enough Evidence To Hold Caldwell

POSTED: Monday, October 4, 2004
UPDATED: 8:06 pm EDT October 4, 2004

The Wayne County Prosecutor announced Monday that the charges against the man suspected of shooting nine people at Hart Plaza were dropped.

Prosecutor Kym Worthy said Monday that forensic evidence failed to link Daron Caldwell, 32, to the shooting scene.

"This action was precipitated by receiving forensic evidence in the late evening of Oct. 1, 2004, that Mr. Caldwell's DNA failed to match any of the physical evidence found at the scene of the shooting," Worthy said.

Caldwell (pictured, left) has maintained his innocence since his arrest in June, Local 4 reported.

"It was overwhelming. It's been a lot on me from day one … They made me look like a menace to society," Caldwell said after his release on Monday.

In spite of Monday's announcement, Detroit police Chief Ella Bully-Cummings and Worthy said that Caldwell could face future charges.

Worthy said Caldwell declined to take a polygraph test upon his arrest. She added that the evidence still points to Caldwell, but there's not enough to prove he is guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.

"While this evidence does not eliminate Mr. Caldwell's participation in the shootings, or his known presence at the crime scene, we cannot proceed with the prosecution of this case at this time," Worthy said. "Please be clear that we do not think we erred in any way, shape, form or fashion in charging Mr. Caldwell."

Caldwell was the prime suspect in the June 23 incident at the International Freedom Festival, where nine people were shot.

The shooting occurred at Woodward and Jefferson, near the Joe Louis Fist statue, just as the fireworks display began shortly after 10 p.m., according to Local 4 reports. Officers from the Detroit Police Violent Crimes Task Force arrested Caldwell at a barber shop on Dexter and Tyler streets on the city's west side at about 6 p.m. the next day.

Timeline: People Vs. Daron Caldwell

Caldwell was charged with second-degree murder after one of the victims -- 48-year-old Donald Murphy -- died of complications from his wound. Caldwell also faced six counts of assault with intent to murder, felon in possession, felony firearm and habitual second offender charges, according to the prosecutor's office.

Within hours of the shooting on June 23, police said three people identified him as the shooter, but at a preliminary examination on a later date, most witnesses could not place him at the scene, the station reported.

Caldwell's supporters claimed that he was at the Shorecrest Motor Inn hotel when the shooting took place.

"There was plenty of eyewitnesses that seen him watch the fireworks on television," said one woman.

Murphy's twin brother, Ronald, told Local 4 that with Caldwell's release, he lost the closure he and his family had in feeling that his brother's killer was in custody.

"We're back to square one. Someone is still out on the streets that they got to look for," he said.

Worthy said Monday that there is new evidence that suggests a second gun may have been used in the shootings.

"The fired evidence suggests that there was more than one weapon used in this particular case," she said.

The evidence was taken from a bullet recovered from one of the shooting victims, Local 4 reported.

Police continue their search for 24-year-old Gary Williams (pictured, right), who investigators initially believed may have been connected to the shooting.

Caldwell, Supporters Maintained His Innocence

Monday's announcement left a sigh of relief for Daron Caldwell, and his family and friends.

Caldwell and his supporters have maintained his innocence since the accusations began, with some wearing T-shirts stating "Not Guilty" during his court appearances.

His attorney said Monday that he is grateful the community rallied behind him, pressuring law enforcement to come to the right conclusion.

"He said it has been a living hell back there," Caldwell attorney Marlon Evans said about his client. "He said it is one thing to be locked up for something you know you are responsible for, it's another thing to be locked up for something that you know you didn't do."

Caldwell's mother, Blanche Thomas, said she feels wonderful "after feeling so terrible for months on end. Not sleeping. Not eating. I am good."

Hot Topics

All 4 Halloween
Friday Football Frenzy - High School Football Highlights
Links We Like
Sponsored Content
You can pick your friends, but not your family -- or your neighbors. Here's what you need to know about how to deal with yours. More

Find out what a sputtering economy and an increasingly difficult to crack job market means to you. More

Are you often tired or rushed in the morning? Give your morning habits a makeover, and start the day feeling positive and energetic instead. More

If you're looking to save on your next new vehicle, a low sticker price is just one aspect. Consider all the costs and make the right decision. More

Hot Shots!

Fantastics Fall Colors
Share your Hot Shots of fantastic fall colors from Michigan's one of a kind tree lines to pumpkin patches!
More
Slideshow: Fall Colors

High School Football Highlights
Send us your Hot Shot photos of football action. Once your Hot Shot gets posted, show it off to all of your friends!
More

Slideshow: Football Frenzy Hot Shots

Sponsored Links

On Local 4

Days Of Our Lives
NBC’s daytime drama “Days of our Lives” will hold its first ever talent and fan search in Detroit at the MGM Grand on Friday, Nov.13 and Saturday, Nov. 14. More

www.DaysOfOurLives.com

See how a local middle school student stopped the bullies cold without a punch! She used simple body language tricks that we'll show your kids how to do.

Morning Home Delivery From Click On Detroit and Local 4 News

Most Popular

Question Of The Day

Have you ever gone onto Facebook or other social networks at work?