Mich. AG casts doubt on impact of federal no-parole juvenile ruling

Attorney General Bill Schuette believes judge's ruling on juvenile lifers won't be applied to all

Published On: Feb 13 2013 03:28:25 PM EST   Updated On: Feb 13 2013 03:45:46 PM EST
Court room gavel
DETROIT -

Michigan Attorney General Bill Schuette believes a judge's recent opinion on no-parole sentences for juveniles covers only five prisoners and is not a sweeping decision affecting other inmates.

Schuette's comments are in a letter to 83 county prosecutors. He says he wants to dispel what he calls "rumors" in news reports following a recent decision by federal Judge John Corbett O'Meara.

O'Meara said Michigan prisoners should have a "fair and meaningful" shot at parole now that the U.S. Supreme Court has struck down mandatory no-parole sentences for crimes committed by teens, mostly murder. The judge said Michigan's parole law is unconstitutional.

MORE: Michigan court limits US ruling on juvenile lifer

But Schuette interprets O'Meara's decision as affecting only a handful of inmates who filed a lawsuit, not hundreds behind bars.

Attorney Deborah LaBelle disagrees. More court action is planned.

More than 350 prisoners in Michigan are serving mandatory no-parole sentences for murders committed when they were under 18.

That's one of the highest totals in the U.S.