Court hearing held for 2 charged in Macomb Township teen's murder, mutilation

Andrew Fiacco, Eevette MacDonald charged in Stephen McAfee's murder

ROMEO, Mich. - Disturbing details emerged the last time Andrew Fiacco and his ex-girlfriend were in court for charges in connection with Stephen McAfee's death and dismemberment.

The two returned to court Wednesday in connection with the murder and mutilation, and police revealed a single tip led them to a break in the case.

McAfee went missing from his Macomb Township home in March 2016. Detectives searched for any sign of him as they followed up on tips. Posters were placed around the community and even a private investigator was hired to help figure out what happened to the 19-year-old. But the case went cold. 

Stephen McAfee

More than a year later, in April 2017, a female walked into the Macomb County Sheriff's Department and revealed Eevette Renee MacDonald, 18, allegedly confided in her that she helped dispose of McAfee's body by hiding it in shallow graves near the Fiacco family home in Ray Township. Other remains were left at the scene of the murder near 34 Mile Road and Van Dyke. 

On April 27, 2017, Sheriff’s investigators searched two locations: A vacant property in Bruce Township and Fiacco’s home in Ray Township. Evidence and remains were located at both locations, the Sheriff's Office said. Lower extremity remains and a skull were found buried near Fiacco's home, investigators said. Neighbors told Local 4 they watched as a person wearing a jail jump suit showed investigators the area behind the home.

Human remains were found in a shallow grave April 27, 2017 behind a home in Ray Township. (WDIV)

Human remains were found in a shallow grave April 27, 2017 behind a home in Ray Township. (WDIV)

READ: Stephen McAfee murder: Timeline of events


Investigators said Fiacco eventually admitted to shooting McAfee in the face when McAfee allegedly attacked him. 

"(Fiacco) did admit that he drove Mr. McAfee from a Macomb Township location to an address and area at 34 Mile Road in Bruce Township, and they both walked to a wooded area. At one point during their travels he alleged that Mr. McAfee attacked him and (Fiacco) was in possession of a firearm at the time. He did admit that he fired three shots, one into the stomach of Mr. McAfee. And he stated after Mr. McAfee remained on the ground he fired two more shots into Mr. McAfee's back. He subsequently left the scene," Detective Mark Morfino testified in April. 

Andrew Michael Fiacco and Eevette Renee MacDonald at their arraignments April 28, 2017.

MacDonald told investigators Fiacco killed McAfee and showed her the body about a month later, Morfino said.

"She indicated both of them took an ax recovered from Mr. Fiacco's house and cut the body in half," Morfino testified. "They retrieved the lower extremities of Mr. McAfee and also his skull, placed it in a duffel bag and transported it to (Fiacco's) residence. After that they buried the skull and lower extremities at Mr. Fiacco's residence."

READ: Gruesome details emerge during suspects' arraignments in Stephen McAfee murder

Morfino said MacDonald later burned the duffel bag.

Murder, disinterment charges

Fiacco, 19, is charged with first-degree murder, disinterment and mutilation of a dead body, lying to a police officer and felony firearms violations. During his arraignment the prosecutor argued Fiacco should not be released on bond. 

"We're talking about a young man who was shot multiple times, twice in the back, left in this abandoned field dead and decomposed. At which point they showed up a month later and they dismembered and mutilated the body," said Bill Cataldo, assistant Macomb County prosecutor. 

Andrew Fiacco and Eevette MacDonald in court July 19, 2017. (WDIV)

MacDonald, 18, is charged with accessory after the fact to a felony, disinterment and mutilation of a dead body and lying to a police officer.

MacDonald's attorney argued for a $10,000, 10 percent, bond because she is a high school senior who is already enrolled in classes this fall at Macomb Community College. Her bond was set at $20,000.

Both defendants are scheduled to be in court for preliminary examinations Wednesday and Thursday. 

Andrew Fiacco in court Aug. 16, 2017. (WDIV)

Eevette MacDonald in court Aug. 16, 2017. (WDIV)

Motive unclear

In April, investigators and Prosecutor Eric Smith said the motive for this crime was not clear. Investigators said Fiacco gave multiple stories. Smith called it "sketchy."

Andrew Michael Fiacco and Eevette Renee MacDonald

“Their motive is a little sketchy right now," Smith said during a news conference Friday, April 28, 2017. "But after the thorough investigation by the investigators with the Sheriff’s Department, we’re confident in our charges and we’re confident in our ability to prove these charges.”

Sheriff Anthony Wickersham said there is no evidence the homicide was drug-related.

Sign up for ClickOnDetroit breaking news alerts and email newsletters

Copyright 2017 by WDIV ClickOnDetroit - All rights reserved.