What we know about UNC's women's basketball team controversy

Coaching staff placed on leave pending review

By EMANUELLA GRINBERG, CNN
Grant Halverson/Getty Images

Sylvia Hatchell

(CNN) - The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill shocked sports fans Monday with news that the women's basketball coaching staff, including its beloved head coach, were placed on leave pending a review of the program.

But the announcement raised even more questions about the culture of the high-stakes sports program. Here's what we know -- and don't know -- about the situation:

 

The allegations

 

What we know: The school said it initiated the review of the program based on "issues raised by student-athletes and others."

What we don't know: UNC declined to answer questions about the nature of the complaints that prompted the review, citing student and employee privacy rights.

It's not clear if the "issues" that were raised include misconduct allegations directly against the staff, or if the staff is accused of letting a toxic environment prevail among the teammates.

Whatever it was, legal experts said it must have been serious to lead to the suspension of such a revered figure in its sports program.

 

Who's affected?

 

What we know: Four employees, including renowned head coach Sylvia Hatchell, were placed on paid administrative leave.

Hatchell is the fourth winningest coach in NCAA women's college basketball history. She has coached at UNC for 33 seasons.

She was diagnosed with leukemia in October 2013, shortly after she was inducted into the Naismith Memorial Basketball Hall of Fame.

She sat out the entire 2013-14 and returned in 2014 after a series of chemotherapy treatments.

Associate Head Coach Andrew Calder is a longtime friend and colleague of Hatchell. He started coaching the Tar Heels in 1986. Calder led the team when Hatchell stepped down because of her leukemia diagnosis.

Assistant coach Sylvia Crawley was a standout center on the 1994 North Carolina NCAA Championship team. She played in the Olympics and the WNBA before returning for her second coaching stint at UNC for the 2018-19 season.

Assistant Coach and recruiting coordinator Bett Shelby joined the program in 2018.

CNN reached out to Crawley, Calder and Shelby for comment. In a statement, Hatchell pledged to cooperate with the investigation and said she looked forward to its "prompt conclusion."

"My goal has always been to help them become the very best people they can be, on the basketball court and in life. I love each and every one of the players I've coached and would do anything to encourage and support them. They are like family to me. I love them all."

What we don't know: Who is accused of what, specifically, and why they were singled out for administrative leave.

 

The investigation

 

What we know: A private law firm, Parker Poe Adams & Bernstein, will conduct the review to assess the program's "culture" and the "experience" of student-athletes, the school said.

It declined to comment further on the focus of the investigation.

What we don't know: UNC said it does not know the exact timetable for the review's completion, but it promised it will be "thorough and prompt."

The hiring of an outside firm does not necessarily imply a certain kind of investigation, said Susan C. Stone and Kristina Supler, lawyers with Kohrman Jackson & Krantz, who handle cases involving student disciplinary matters and Title IX investigations.

But they said it was a smart move to guard against concerns of conflicts of interest that could arise from an internal review.

It's also not clear of the allegations were reported to the US Department of Education for possible violations of the federal civil right law known as Title IX, which forbids any kind of discrimination based on gender.

The department referred CNN to its page for pending cases currently under investigation.

Different UNC campuses -- including Chapel Hill -- are listed in several open cases involving allegations of sexual discrimination, disability discrimination or racial discrimination. But details of those cases are not publicly available, and it's not clear whether any are linked to the allegations that prompted the independent review of the basketball program.

 

How the players are responding?

 

What we know: So far, none have spoken publicly about the review.

CNN affiliate WRAL reported that three players told the university they intend to transfer.

What we don't know: It's not clear if the decisions are related to the review.

The-CNN-Wire ™ & © 2019 Cable News Network, Inc., a Time Warner Company. All rights reserved.