DETROIT – It’s one of the most brutal murders in Detroit’s history, and after more than 90 years it still remains unsolved.
On the night of July 3, 1929, Benny Evangelist, and his wife and four children were found brutally murdered in their Detroit home, on St. Aubin and Mack.
The killings were carried out with an axe. Evangelist's wife and children were killed while they slept in their beds.
Evangelist was found nearly decapitated at his desk.
Over the many decades since, there have been several theories as to why someone would murder this family.
Who was Benny Evangelist?
Hailed as a "mystic" and "healer," Evangelist was the leader of a so-called cult, who received as much as $10 per "reading," using unorthodox methods to heal both the mentally and physically challenged.
His methods ranged from religion, black magic to prescribing herbal medicine.
Two years after arriving in the U.S., in 1904, Evangelist, an Italian immigrant, claims to have began receiving visions from God.
He published a four-volume "bible" he called "The Oldest History of the World: Discovered by Occult Science," self-describing himself as a prophet.
In his basement, Evangelist constructed an odd spiritual sanctuary consisting of wax dolls and figures hung by wires from the ceiling depicting "celestial planets." The basement served as the "church" for Evangelist's sermons.
He referred to his bible as "the sun."
Evangelist had amounted several enemies, mostly those who believed they were being ripped off. Some claimed that he overcharged them for things like love potions, and promises of cures.
Evangelist family murdered July 3
The night before the murders took place, Evangelist had made a call to the watchman of a house that was being demolished.
He told the watchman that he had purchased all of the salvageable lumber from the wreck, and would arrange for the wood to be picked up and delivered to his home.
The plan was that Evangelist would meet the truck the next morning to pay the deliverymen.
Evangelist and his family were murdered later that night, but the deliverymen were a no-show.
Evangelist had planned to have the money to pay them the following day, yet no cash was found in the home following the murder.
ALSO READ: When the 'Purple Gang' ruled Detroit
Police were never able to locate the name of the delivery company, but suspected money to be a motive.
According to an article posted on July 3 by The United Press, Evangelist's head had been completely severed from his body and was on a chair near the bed in which his and his wife's bodies were found.
Benny, 43, his wife, Santina, 36, their four children, Angeline, 8, Matilda, 5, Jay, 3 and their 18-month-old son, Morrio, were discovered by a neighbor.
Here's the story from The Associated Press on July 3, 1929:
"Sitting before his desk, which also served as an altar, his hands folded as though in prayer, the body of Benny Evangelist, mystic healer and religious fanatic, was found shortly before noon on Wednesday. The head lay on the floor beside the chair. The bodies of his wife and four children found upstairs, their skulls crushed. Police are working on the theory that Evangelist was the victim of a second religious fanatic, It is believed the slayings took place about midnight."
Wayne County coroner James Burgess commented in the paper the following morning:
"This is the most unusual case. A single perverted maniac must have killed them, although it seems impossible that some of their screams would not be heard."
A funeral was held on July 6. A crowd of about 3,000 curious residents packed the streets.
Police hoped they could find a suspect at the funeral, arresting one man who was "acting queerly, with excited suspicion," but was released shortly after.
The search for the killer
On July 4, every police squad in Detroit was ordered to join in a city-wide search for the killer.
Police initially investigated a connection to a murder of a mother and her three children two weeks prior, but the connection was not valid.
No trace of a weapon was found in the home. Police did find bloody fingerprints on the door latch. There was a reward of $1,000 being offered by Detroit police for information.
Angelo Depoli was arrested the day of the murder with a blood covered knife, but police couldn't connect him to the family, despite neighbors claiming he was a frequent visitor at the home.
In March 1930, the AP published a report with the headline "Eye Witness to Brutal Detroit Axe Slaying Finally Turns Up."
The eye witness was a dog. Here's what the report read:
"The witness is a shaggy brown mongrel dog, which belonged to the children of Benny Evangelist. The animal disappeared at the time Evangelist and his wife and the four children were hacked to death on July 3, 1929. In the course of routine a record was made of the dog's license number, but the dog was not found. Yesterday, a woman reported that a dog with a 1929 license number had come to her home. When she learned who had owned the animal she decided not to adopt it."
Three years after the gruesome murders, a man nicknamed the "rear axle murderer," Robert Harris confessed. Police believed they had solved the crime. But after investigating his claims, they found Harris was lying.
There have been leads from time to time, but the case has remained ice cold.
The legend of St. Aubin Street
Many say the land where the family lived, near the corner of St. Aubin and Mack, is haunted.
There have been reports of a headless man seen wandering around, along with disembodied voices and screams.
The house was demolished some years ago -- all that sits in its space is grass.
A book titled “Detroit Occult Murders” details a string of murders between 1929 and 1931 all centered around St. Aubin Street.