Oakland County man charged with child abuse, torture after 3-year-old girl dies Man in custody, denied bond
HOLLY TOWNSHIP, Mich. – An Oakland County man has been charged with child abuse and torture after a 3-year-old girl was pronounced dead last weekend .
Samuel Lester Smart is being held in the Oakland County lockup after a judge denied his bond. He’s charged with beating Trinity Chandler, who was pronounced dead on Saturday in Holly Township .
READ : Family says Child Protective Services had been called prior to death of 3-year-old Holly Township girl
Family members said Trinity’s mother was working an overnight shift at a nursing home when she got a text from her Smart. They said Smart reported that Trinity wasn’t waking up and he took her to a nearby fire station.
An Michigan State Police investigator told the court that there is video of the little girl being abused. Just a day before she was pronounced dead, Child Protective Services did a welfare check on her.
Trinity Chandler is Ronda Osterberg’s great-niece.
“They failed her. They failed her big time,” Ronda Osterberg said. “There were two black eyes, there was a bruise on her cheek -- CPS closed the case.”
The family said they’re devastated.
Copyright 2020 by WDIV ClickOnDetroit - All rights reserved.
About the Authors Kayla Clarke headshot
Kayla is a Web Producer for ClickOnDetroit. Before she joined the team in 2018 she worked at WILX in Lansing as a digital producer.
Michigan's Dusty May on Yaxel's health, team depth ▶ 1:05
Michigan's Dusty May on Yaxel's health, team depth
5 Tips for Road Rage ▶ 0:54
5 Tips for Road Rage
Trey McKenney on chasing national title ▶ 1:27
Trey McKenney on chasing national title
Wayne County family's property hit by powerful storms ▶ 2:21
Wayne County family's property hit by powerful storms
Lendeborg gives injury status for Monday, Cadeau talks mentality ahead of title game ▶ 1:08
Lendeborg gives injury status for Monday, Cadeau talks mentality ahead of title game
Did you know this about Michigan Humane? ▶ 0:48
Did you know this about Michigan Humane?
Michigan basketball gears up for Arizona in Final Four showdown ▶ 1:15
Michigan basketball gears up for Arizona in Final Four showdown
Michigan basketball center Aday Mara's parents join him at Final Four ▶ 1:30
Michigan basketball center Aday Mara's parents join him at Final Four
Former inmate awarded $307.6M over denied surgery ▶ 0:43
Former inmate awarded $307.6M over denied surgery
Bricks falling, windows gone: Detroit home sparks alarm ▶ 0:35
Bricks falling, windows gone: Detroit home sparks alarm
Behind the Scenes at Opening Day w/ Live in the D ▶ 0:38
Behind the Scenes at Opening Day w/ Live in the D
How the Zipper Merge Helps Reduce Traffic ▶ 1:01
How the Zipper Merge Helps Reduce Traffic
Livonia officer stabbed inside police station lobby ▶ 0:45
Livonia officer stabbed inside police station lobby
Tarp comes off at Comerica Park for Opening Day ▶ 0:31
Tarp comes off at Comerica Park for Opening Day
A look at Detroit Tigers fashion ⚾🐯 ▶ 1:01
A look at Detroit Tigers fashion ⚾🐯
Behind the scenes at Comerica Park for Opening Day! ▶ 1:25
Behind the scenes at Comerica Park for Opening Day!
How to get half-off Lyft rides for Tigers Opening Day ▶ 1:25
How to get half-off Lyft rides for Tigers Opening Day
How to drive in a roundabout ▶ 0:40
How to drive in a roundabout
LITD Comerica Park Groundskeeper ▶ 1:27
LITD Comerica Park Groundskeeper
Officer placed on administrative duty after repeatedly punching man ▶ 1:12
Officer placed on administrative duty after repeatedly punching man
Ecorse city controller arrested in Wisconsin ▶ 0:38
Ecorse city controller arrested in Wisconsin
Family claims school covered up wrestling hazing ▶ 0:40
Family claims school covered up wrestling hazing
Live In The D hosts share their dance moves ▶ 1:10
Live In The D hosts share their dance moves
Ecorse apartment residents react to eviction warning ▶ 0:43
Ecorse apartment residents react to eviction warning
Woman says credit union withheld deceased father’s money ▶ 0:39
Woman says credit union withheld deceased father’s money
Previous photo Next photo