Ex-Inkster officer William Melendez appeals sentence; court affirms decision
INKSTER, Mich. – Former Inkster police officer William Melendez filed an appeal in another attempt to walk away from a sentence of 13 moths to 10 years for the violent beating of a driver during a traffic stop and the appeals court has denied it.
Twelve months after his conviction, Melendez asked for release at a parole hearing because he alleges he suffers from PTSD. Wayne County Prosecutor Kym Worthy sent a scathing letter to the parole board opposing his release.
Now, Melendez has filed an appeal alleging a Fifth Amendment violation in regards to when he was interviewed, and that the court abused its discretion by admitting evidence of a history of using racial slurs.
The appeal also alleged improper voir dire, prosecutorial error and exclusion of impeachment evidence.
The appeals court affirmed the lower courts ruling and Melendez remains behind bars.
The judge said during sentencing that Melendez engaged in "cowardly acts of barbaric behavior" and excessive force when he punched a driver in the head 16 times during a traffic stop.
“You were so into your bravado that you forgot the eye of justice was recording you," Judge Vonda Evans told William Melendez. “You knew better. You were better trained that any of those officers out there. You were more experienced.”
Evans was referencing the dashcam camera that captured the beating on Jan. 28, 2015. The Local 4 Defenders were the first to air it, which sparked an investigation that led to the resignation of the then-Inskster police chief and assault and misconduct in office against Melendez.
“They put me out of my own car and beat me,” Dent Local 4 in an interview. “I have to live with that every day.”
Melendez and his partner began following Dent's Cadillac when he failed to stop at a stop sign and wouldn't pull over when the patrol car turned its lights on.
"When the overhead lights came on, I looked and said, "Wow. Are they stopping me?' So, I just kept going until I realized that they were really stopping me," Dent said.
Dent was driving on a suspended license and police said they found a bag of crack cocaine under a seat. After the incident, Dent was charged with assaulting a police officer, resisting arrest and possession of cocaine.
Dent passed a lie detector test and his fingerprints weren’t found on the baggie of white powder that was found in his car. The charges against him were eventually dropped. He settled with the City of Inkster for $1.4 million.
Melendez went to trial and was convicted on the assault and misconduct charges. He was acquitted on a strangulation charge.
"When your posse arrived, they joined you in a take down, kicking and Tasing and ultimately throwing Mr. Dent into a windshield of a police car," Evans said.
She added that Dent was "dead wrong" for driving without a license and not following the rules of the road. But she said Melendez didn't do his job and played a game.
"You will pay for two things: not being an example of greatness, which I know that you are from all the letters of support, awards and commendation that you have shared with this court, and resorting to cowardly acts of barbaric behavior that led you to be convicted of these crimes," Evans said. "I can only punish your conduct, but only you and God can change your character."
She sentenced him to 13 months to 10 years on an assault with intent to do great bodily harm charge and 90 days on a misconduct in office charge. He will be given 85 days credit for time served.
Local 4's coverage
- Final chapter in Inkster police beating; Melendez to be sentenced
- Floyd Dent discusses Melendez verdict
- Jury convicts Melendez of assault, misconduct; Not guilty of strangulation charge
- Judge Evans scolds Melendez's wife for storming out of courtroom
- Floyd Dent settles suit with city of Inkster for $1.4 million
- Preliminary exam set for former Inkster police officer charged in Floyd Dent beating
- Defenders exclusive: New video shows Inkster cops laughing while Floyd Dent bleeds
- Inkster Police Chief Vicki Yost resigns
- New video shows bloody Floyd Dent in Inkster jail
- Charges against Floyd Dent dismissed; Ex-Inkster officer charged with assault
- Local 4 Defenders: Violent traffic stop in Inkster caught on camera
Copyright 2016 by WDIV ClickOnDetroit - All rights reserved.